Insights Articles

Articles

Stock Market Recap: April 2024


  • April saw major bond and stock markets decline due to a shifting interest rate outlook, following higher-than-expected inflation data. The S&P 500 had its first 5% or greater drop since October 2023 in April.
  • In the equity market – areas with greater sensitivity to high interest rates lagged, such as small cap stocks (-7.04%, Russell 2000 TR Index). Large cap stocks also declined, with value stocks down -4.27% (Russell 1000 Value TR Index) and growth stocks down -4.24% (Russell 1000 Growth TR Index). Emerging market equities bucked the trend and finished in positive territory (+0.45% MSCI Emerging Market NR Index).
  • As of April 30th, investors were no longer pricing a cut to the Fed Fund rate for 2024, leading major bond markets to 2024 lows (-2.53% in April, Bloomberg Barclays Aggregate Bond TR Index).

Large growth companies continue to drive a large portion of the US equity market’s results during the past three and five years – April was no different. The S&P 500 (weighted by the size of the companies in the index) has outperformed the equal-weighted S&P 500 (representing the results of the average company) by an increasingly wide margin over the past 18 to 24 months.

This has been driven by fast-growing technology companies: technology stocks represent roughly 30% of the market-cap weighted S&P 500, compared to 14% weight in the equal-weighted S&P 500. However, it is important to adopt a longer perspective during these unusual periods. Over the past 15- and 20-year periods, as well as since 2003 – the equal weighted S&P 500 index is ahead or in-line with the market cap weighted S&P 500. On a calendar year basis, the equal-weighted S&P 500 has finished ahead 12 out of 21 years through 2023.

Although the market has been very top heavy, with the fast-growing technology companies driving the market, markets are cyclical, and longer-time horizons highlight the balance over time.

Source: Raymond James, FactSet. Data as of 2/29/2024. Since inception date of the equal-weighted is 1/3/2003.
  • Inflation data will be top-of-mind given the recent hot streak in data. Federal Reserve commentary around the data will also be closely watched by investors.
  • First quarter 2024 earnings will wrap up in May. Through the end of April, earnings have finished ahead of expectations for S&P 500 companies that have reported. 
William Winkeler
About the Author

Bill has more than 12 years of experience in the investment industry, most recently as Managing Director of Investments at a private wealth management firm. In his role at Confluence, Bill chairs the…

Insights Articles

Articles

Navigating Estate Taxes: 4 Mistakes to Avoid


In the past decade, estate tax conversations have been steadily decreasing. As the lifetime credit has climbed to unprecedented highs, many wealthy Americans have come to believe that they are safely out of Uncle Sam’s reach. However, recent history is just that, it’s recent. Historically, estate taxes have been a major factor for both middle class and high-net-worth Americans. Furthermore, estate taxes are often easy targets for adjustments when fiscal gaps need closing. This article explores why estate taxes should continue to be a priority in your wealth planning, and how you can be prepared for whatever the future may hold.

Don’t Assume Estate Taxes Won’t Be a Problem

The current estate tax lifetime exemption is $13.61MM per individual, or $27.22MM per couple. These numbers have become so high in recent years, that many high-net-worth Americans have come to believe that they no longer need to worry about estate taxes. My advice is to be careful, because congress can change the rules at any time. As recently as 2008, the exemption was only $2MM per individual, and it was even lower than that in the 1990s and early 2000s. Even under current law if nothing else changes, the $13.61MM exclusion will be cut in half on January 1st of 2026. When tax shortfalls arise, estate taxes are often viewed as low hanging fruit for Washington. The current exclusion level is an aberration, not the historical norm.

Don’t Let Your Estate Documents Become Stale

The rule of thumb for most families is to have their estate plan documents reviewed every 5 years. However, if you are a high-net-worth individual with an estate tax issue, these reviews should be much more frequent. In fact, estate tax considerations should be a part of your financial plan to be reviewed and discussed at least annually and perhaps more if there is a significant change in the law. Vehicles such as irrevocable trusts and joint insurance policies can help mitigate the risk of owing estate taxes, and these vehicles and strategies should be a part of the normal cadence of planning.

Don’t Forget to Incorporate Charitable Giving into Your Estate Plan

Charitable giving is one of the many strategic ways to avoid estate taxes, especially if you’ve already set aside the amounts that you plan to leave to your children. Wealth that is left to charitable organizations is not subject to the 40% estate tax. This means that instead of giving $600K to your children and $400k to the government, you give $1MM to an organization you care about, or to a foundation or Donor Advised Fund that is run by your children. Most people would prefer that their heirs decide which causes receive those funds rather than a large chunk being sent to Washington.

Make Sure You Have the Right Team:

Your team of professionals should include not only an excellent wealth manager who can help you plan around these issues, but also an attorney and a CPA who are experts in their fields when it comes to estate taxes. These issues are complex, and they can change quickly. Make sure that you are working with professionals who have the knowledge and the bandwidth to give these issues the attention they deserve.

Estate planning is a dynamic field that requires regular attention, especially for those with significant wealth. High-net-worth individuals should not only reassess their estate plans frequently but should also consider incorporating charitable giving as part of their strategy. Be sure your planning team includes knowledgeable wealth managers, attorneys, and CPAs as this is crucial as you navigate the ever-changing landscape of estate taxes. Complacency can be costly – proactive estate planning should remain a critical element of your financial health.

If we can be of help to you and your family, please give us a call!

Randy Holcombe
About the Author

The opportunity to make a positive difference in people’s lives is why Randy chose a career in wealth management. He is passionate about helping his clients achieve their goals and cut through the…

Confluence Financial Partners and its affiliates do not provide tax, legal or accounting advice. This material has been prepared for informational purposes only, and is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on for, tax, legal or accounting advice. You should consult your own tax, legal and accounting advisors before engaging in any transaction.

Insights Articles

Articles

Your Financial Guide for a Career Transition


Navigating a job change is a significant undertaking, especially for those with considerable assets and financial interests. This guide is designed for professionals, including executives, physicians, and business owners as they work through the intricacies of transitioning to new opportunities.

Here are some important things to consider:

  • Review your compensation plan.

Understanding your compensation package is important, because compensation is usually a huge part of transition decision. Beyond salary, bonuses, and deferred compensation, it’s essential to assess the long-term value of your total package. For example, if you are re-locating, consider the impact of cost-of-living adjustments.

Don’t forget to evaluate non-monetary benefits such as professional development opportunities, wellness opportunities, and overall company culture. All of these can have a significant impact on your job satisfaction and overall well-being.

  • Evaluate your retirement plan.

What do I do with my old retirement plan(s)?

Roll into an IRA: Working with a financial advisor can help you determine if rolling into an Individual Retirement Account makes sense. The benefits of this option include having more investment flexibility and control. Typically, you will have a broader range of investment options compared to an employer sponsored 401(k) plan. This allows you to diversify your portfolio while also consolidating accounts if you have multiple 401(k)s with previous employers. If you work with an advisor, you will have professional investment management as well as financial planning available. A good financial advisor will also be able to help with tax and estate planning matters, though he/she cannot replace your CPA or attorney.

or

Move your old retirement plan to your new employer: Most employer sponsored retirement plans allow for assets from previous retirement plans to flow into the new plan. This is certainly better than leaving the assets with your old employer’s plan, but this option likely does not include the investment options and flexibility as well as professional management and planning found if you roll assets into a managed IRA. That said, it may be your lowest cost option.

  • Understand changes to your health insurance.

Be aware if there is a waiting period for health insurance with your new employer. If that is the case, look into extending your previous employer’s coverage through COBRA if there is a gap.

Have a solid understanding of the different health insurance plans offered by your employer and consider factors such as the network of providers, deductibles, co-pays, coverage for prescription drugs and preventative care to name a few.

Take advantage of  tax-advantaged accounts like Flexible Spending Accounts (FSA)s and Health Savings Accounts (HSA)s if your employer offers them.  These accounts can help you save money on qualified medical expenses. Additionally, HSAs can serve as an additional retirement savings vehicle.

  • Review Stock Options and Equity Compensation Programs.

If your previous employer offered stock options or equity, be sure to understand the vesting schedules and the implications of leaving.

Equity compensation can significantly increase your wealth, but also add complexity to your financial and tax planning picture. For example, the decision to exercise stock options should be timed to optimize tax implications and align with your broader financial goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon. Working with a financial advisor can help you make an informed financial decision.

Melissa Pirosko
About the Author

Melissa’s love of investing combined with her desire to help and serve others led her to a career in wealth management. Melissa enjoys working with clients to help them reach their financial goals…

Insights Articles

Articles

Stock Market Recap: March 2024


  • Stock and bond markets rallied during March, with broadening of results- large cap value stocks (+5.0%, Russell 1000 Value TR Index), small cap stocks (+3.6%, Russell 2000 TR Index), and international stocks (+3.3%, MSCI ACWI Ex-USA NR Index) finished the month ahead of large cap growth stocks (+1.8%, Russell 1000 Growth TR Index).
  • Economic data continues to look strong in the United States. The Federal Reserve also confirmed their forecast of three 0.25% interest rate cuts in 2024.

Last month we discussed the difficulty in forecasting changes in interest rates. During March, investors spent the month aligning their outlook with the Federal Reserve’s guidance, which remains some level of interest rate cuts sometime later this year. While the exact timing cannot be known, we do know that historically there have been opportunities to shift out of cash investments near peak interest rates.

Going back to the six previous cycles since 1984, investors have been better off investing in bonds, US stocks or a balanced portfolio compared to staying in cash during the 12-months following the peak level of interest rates. Forecasting the exact time of peak interest rates/rate cuts is fruitless, but for long-term investors there is an opportunity to look beyond cash.

Source: Bloomberg, FactSet, Federal Reserve, Robert Shiller, J.P. Morgan Asset Management. The 60/40 portfolio is 60% invested in S&P 500 Total Return Index and 40% invested in Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Total Return Index. The S&P 500 total return figure from the 1984 period was calculated using data from Robert Shiller. The analysis references the month in which the month-end 6-month CD rate peaked during previous rate hiking cycles. CD rate data prior to 2013 are sourced from the Federal Reserve, whereas data from 2013 to 2023 are sourced from Bloomberg. CD subsequent 12-month return calculation assumes reinvestment at the prevailing 6-month rate when the initial CD matures.

  • The Federal Reserve meets at the end of April, they are expected to hold interest rates constant. Investors will look for updates around the timing of interest rate cuts and balance sheet changes during the presentation. 
  • The inflation report and jobs report for March will be watched by investors for signs of continued progress on the inflation front, and for any weakening in the jobs market.
William Winkeler
About the Author

Bill has more than 12 years of experience in the investment industry, most recently as Managing Director of Investments at a private wealth management firm. In his role at Confluence, Bill chairs the…

Insights Articles

Articles

How to Optimize Metabolic Health Through Lifestyle


The human body is intricately detailed and complex, similar to a car. While many of us don’t comprehend a car’s inner workings, we can sense when something is “off” and impacting optimal functionality. Similarly to a check engine light flipped on, there are many cues the body gives that it’s utilizing food for fuel less than optimally, such as the following: cravings, weight struggles, energy slumps, relentless fatigue, etc. Sadly, many of us have ignored these signals for too long.

The engine of the car is likened to the body’s metabolism. Just as the engine converts fuel into usable energy so the car can operate, being in good metabolic health ensures our body is able to generate and process energy efficiently to sustain life.

What factors determine metabolic health, you may wonder?

Clinically, it hinges on five specific and measurable factors¹:

  1. Abdominal obesity (>40” around waist in men, >35” around waist in women)
  2. Impaired fasted blood sugar (100 mg/dL or higher)
  3. High blood pressure (130/85 mm/Hg or higher on multiple occasions or on medication for high levels)
  4. High triglycerides (type of fat; 150 mg/dL or greater or on medication for high levels)
  5. Low “helpful” cholesterol (HDL) levels (<40 mg/dL for men, <50 mg/dL for women)

According to the recent study published in the Journal of American College of Cardiology in July 2022, it’s estimated that only ~7% of adult Americans adults have optimal metabolic health, leaving 93% with markers in unhealthy ranges².

Each marker out of range increases the risk for development of complications like heart disease, Type 2 Diabetes, or stroke. Three or more out of range is considered metabolic syndrome. Getting an annual physical exam and bloodwork empowers your healthcare provider to evaluate your risk for metabolic syndrome. The good news is that lifestyle choices highly influence the health of these markers – namely eating a balanced diet and shunning a sedentary existence as two very practical realms to target.

Nutritionally, a balanced diet revolves around diverse, nutrient-rich whole foods while limiting processed items. A simple example of this would be choosing an apple (whole form) as opposed to apple sauce or apple juice, as often as is doable. This is due to the quality of nutrients the whole form contains as opposed to added processing.

When it comes to energy, the body’s preferred fuel source is glucose (think of this like gasoline), which comes from eating carbohydrates (carbs). In simplest terms, when we eat foods containing carbs, our blood sugars rise (as we expect). In those with good metabolic health, the body efficiently takes that glucose and converts it into usable energy and blood sugar levels are returned to normal through a process of hormonal “checks and balances”.

Conversely, poor metabolic health impedes glucose being used for energy efficiently, but rather leaves it in the blood stream, hence the term “high blood sugar”. When levels are high in the moment, you may experience the check engine symptoms listed above. Over time, chronically elevated blood sugar levels can lead to conditions like Type 2 Diabetes. When it comes to managing blood sugar levels – a quick tip you can implement today is the principle of “no naked carbs”.

A sedentary lifestyle can be described as one marked by excessive sitting, lying down, and not engaging intentionally in physical activities that would increase heart rate or test muscle tone. For many Americans, especially depending on time of year and where one lives, this can include commute time to work, working from home sitting in front of a computer for most of the day, television watching, video game playing, etc.

Lack of movement, especially after eating food, can be disadvantageous for metabolic health as it can promote an “insulin resistant” state. Movement, like exercise (as simple as walking at a brisk pace or weight lifting) can promote “insulin sensitivity” which allows the body to utilize the incoming sources of foods more efficiently. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services recommends the American adult to engage in physical activity categorized as moderate-intensity of 150 minutes per week and optimally 2 days of muscle strengthening, also³. This helps not only with metabolic health, but weight maintenance, mood, increasing “helpful” cholesterol (HDL), increasing creativity and promoting longevity, among many other benefits.

No matter where your starting point is, it’s time to get moving!

This introductory overview offers a flyover look into the intricacies of metabolic health, distinguishing between manifestations and potential risks. I hope you are encouraged that lifestyle factors like what you eat (good nutrition) and how much you move (exercise) can greatly reduce your risk for chronic disease, keeping your “engine” operating efficiently. By fostering awareness of the importance of metabolic health, we can be proactive in our approach to reducing risk factors. Time to take a look “under the hood” of your car!

Sarah Rupp
About the Author

Sarah’s lifelong passion for health and wellness began in her early years, learning about nutrition and meal planning alongside her mother. As an athlete, she experienced the direct influence of nutrition on physical…

McMurray

Sources:

  1. Ndumele, Chiadi E, MD, MHS. The Metabolic Syndrome. Johns Hopkins Medicine. Accessed 14 March 2024. https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/conditions-and-diseases/the-metabolic-syndrome
  2. O’Hearn, M, Lauren, B, Wong, J. et al. Trends and Disparities in Cardiometabolic Health Among U.S. Adults, 1999-2018. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2022 Jul, 80 (2) 138–151.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jacc.2022.04.046
  3. How much physical activity do adults need? Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Accessed 14 March 2024. https://www.cdc.gov/physicalactivity/basics/adults/index.htm#:~:text=Each%20week%20adults%20need%20150,Physical%20Activity%20Guidelines%20for%20Americans.

Healthcare Disclaimer: The contents of this article are meant for educational purposes and not to be misconstrued as medical treatment advice. Please speak with a qualified healthcare provider regarding personalized guidance regarding your specific medical condition before making changes to your unique plan of care.

Insights Articles

Articles

Stock Market Recap: February 2024


Month in Review

  • Rally continued for stocks in February, with the key development of broader participation- for example, US small cap stocks had a strong month.
  • String of inflation data and commentary from the Federal Reserve pushed bond yields higher during February.
  • The inflation report released during the month (January CPI) showed prices rising more than expected, driven by higher housing related costs.

Investors are curious as to when the Federal Reserve will start lowering interest rates. During February, investors recalibrated expectations once again for the start of rate cuts, believing that the first reduction will be pushed back to June 2024. This change makes sense for various reasons: inflation continues to remain somewhat firm, and the labor market remains very strong.

Historically, forecasting the path of interest rates has been notoriously difficult to do and ultimately, introduces unwarranted noise into investors’ outlooks. The chart below shows how even the Federal Reserve struggles to predict its own interest rate decisions.

Source: Capital Group, Bloomberg. As of February 23, 2024. Federal funds rate data from January 2016 to February 2024. Forward looking dot plot projections are reported quarterly from September 2016 through December 2023.

  • Inflation data will be in focus as investors watch for any signs of continued increases of prices. The February CPI report is released on March 12th and expected to show declining inflation.
  • The Federal Reserve’s March meeting (FOMC) will be closely watched for commentary around the outlook for growth and inflation. Fed Chair Jerome Powell has already indicated a March rate hike is off the table.
  • As of February 29th, 97% of the S&P 500 companies had reported earnings, with the remainder wrapping up in March. With 97% of companies reporting, year-over-year earnings growth came in at +4%. 
William Winkeler
About the Author

Bill has more than 12 years of experience in the investment industry, most recently as Managing Director of Investments at a private wealth management firm. In his role at Confluence, Bill chairs the…

Insights Articles

Articles

Disability Insurance Planning for Physicians: Key Facts & Considerations


Nearly 1 in 5 people living in the United States will suffer a disability lasting more than one year before the age of 65.1


Imagine not being able to practice your specialized medical skills due to illness or injury. The financial impact could be devastating for you and your family. As a physician, your income hinges on your ability to work. That’s why individual disability insurance as part of your financial plan is crucial for safeguarding your earning potential.

Choosing disability insurance involves understanding the different types and the benefits each brings. For example, there are two categories of disability policies, short-term disability and long-term disability. Short-term disability policies are typically obtained as a group policy benefit from one’s employer while long-term disability policies are also offered as a benefit through an employer BUT are more commonly purchased as an individual policy through a broker or financial advisor.

Additionally, you can purchase own-occupation coverage or any-occupation coverage. The difference between the two is meaningful. Under an own-occupation policy, a person is typically considered disabled if they are unable to perform the material and substantial duties of the job they were working at the time they became disabled. Under an any-occupation policy, a person is considered disabled if they are not able to perform substantial duties of any job for which the person may earn a certain percentage of their pre-disability earnings.  

For physicians, it is essential to work with an advisor who understands your needs and unique situation to recommend the right disability insurance strategy.

Beyond basic understanding of disability insurance, it’s important to understand key factors like the carrier, benefit amount, elimination period, and renewal options.

  • Insurance Carrier – know who you are working with. Currently, only 5 carriers offer “true” own-occupation coverage.
  • Benefit Amount – the IRS publishesd “Issue & Participation” amounts based on your income and existing disability coverage.
  • Waiting Period – the amount of time one must wait to collect benefits when disabled – typically 90, 180, 365, or 730 days.
  • Benefit Period – how long one will be eligible to receive their tax-free benefit. This is typically to age 65, 67, 70, or lifetime.

The above list is not all encompassing but should be considered as you construct your insurance package.

At Confluence Financial Partners, we work with physicians to secure and protect their income in the event an unexpected illness or injury becomes reality. Please reach out if you would like to start the conversation today.

Life and disability insurance and life insurance with long-term care benefits are not issued through Confluence Insurance Services. Products and services referenced are offered and sold only by appropriately appointed and licensed entities and financial advisors and professionals. Not all products and services are available in all states. 

  1. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Disability and Health Data System (DHDS) [Internet]. [updated 2023 May; cited 2023 May 15]. Available from: http://dhds.cdc.gov
      ↩︎
Rob Linkowski
About the Author

Rob Linkowski brings more than 30 years of experience in designing and providing quality life and disability insurance programs to his clientele of medical professionals, business owners, family and friends. Rob is passionate…

Insights Articles

Articles

Multi-Generational Legacies: Communicating Your Estate Plan


$96 Trillion is going to pass from one generation to the next over the coming 30 years.

This is either going to go smoothly or poorly, and much of that answer will come down to estate planning.

Your estate plan is a crucial aspect of securing your family’s future, and communicating this plan effectively to your children is perhaps even more important.

  1. Talk About It

This might seem basic, but start the conversation early. Don’t wait for a crisis to discuss your estate plan. Start the conversation with your children while everyone is in good health and spirits. Choose a suitable time and place for the discussion, ensuring minimal distractions. This will allow your children to focus on the important matters at hand without feeling rushed or pressured.

  • Clarify Roles and Responsibilities

Clearly communicate who will be responsible for executing your wishes and managing your affairs if you are unable to do so. If your adult children will be filling these roles, tell them. Don’t assume that your oldest child will understand why you made your middle child the executor. Explain your decisions and choices so that when the time comes there won’t be any confusion or hurt feelings.  

  • Educate Your Heirs on the Structure of Your Estate Plan

You don’t have to share all of the details right away, but make a plan for bringing in the next generation into your financial picture. These discussions are difficult to begin in most households, but at some point you should consider letting your adult children know what you have and how all of it will be transferred. Eventually you should share detailed information about your assets, including properties, investments, and savings. Do you have a financial plan with your financial advisor? It would be wise to share it with your children.

When in doubt, over communicate. You would be amazed at the disagreements that will come up after you are gone, many of which are due to a lack of direction and clarity on your part. Don’t assume your children will know what to do. Spell it out for them.

  • Address Potential Concerns and Questions

You don’t have to share all of the details right away, but make a plan for bringing in the next generation into your financial picture. These discussions are difficult to begin in most households, but at some point you should consider letting your adult children know what you have and how all of it will be transferred. Eventually you should share detailed information about your assets, including properties, investments, and savings. Do you have a financial plan with your financial advisor? It would be wise to share it with your children.

When in doubt, over communicate. You would be amazed at the disagreements that will come up after you are gone, many of which are due to a lack of direction and clarity on your part. Don’t assume your children will know what to do. Spell it out for them.

Randy Holcombe
About the Author

The opportunity to make a positive difference in people’s lives is why Randy chose a career in wealth management. He is passionate about helping his clients achieve their goals and cut through the…

Insights Articles

Articles

Stock Market Recap: January 2024


  • It was a choppy month for stock and bond markets as volatility rose towards the end of January. US large caps squeezed out a positive return, while US small caps and international equities trailed.
  • Investors pushed expectations of interest rate cuts out, helping to increase interest rates, which weighed on major bond markets during the month.
  • Economic data remains strong enough that the Federal Reserve largely took a March rate cut off the table in late January.

The S&P 500 reached a new all-time high on January 25th, illustrating the progress the equity market has made following the most recent bear market. Along with making new all-time highs comes an influx of short-term noise, making it important to review the history of market returns following bear market recoveries. Looking at all 14 cases since 1957, the S&P 500 rose an average of 23% over the 18 month period following the 20% recovery from a bear market low. In present day, the S&P 500 had a bear market low on October 12, 2022, and recovered 20% roughly 9 months later in June 2023. Ignoring short-termism around all-time highs, history suggests the equity markets continue to rise after recovering from a bear market.   

Source: Yahoo! Finance as of 1/30/2024; BMO Capital Markets via Brian Belski.

  • Earnings season will wrap up, after companies posted largely mixed results in January. 
  • Banks are back in focus following the surprise weakness in some regional bank earnings. Given the events of March/April 2023, investors have heightened sensitivity to any perceived weakness in the banking channel.
  • The Federal Reserve does not have a (FOMC) meeting in February, so investors will look for additional information from Fed officials following the January meeting. The Federal Reserve surprised investors by taking a March rate cut off the table, suggesting it would happen later in 2024 depending on economic data.
William Winkeler
About the Author

Bill has more than 12 years of experience in the investment industry, most recently as Managing Director of Investments at a private wealth management firm. In his role at Confluence, Bill chairs the…

Insights Articles

Articles

Navigating the Maze: Understanding and Maximizing Your RSU & ISO Benefits


Many companies offer equity compensation programs to attract, motivate, and retain top talent while conserving cash and aligning the interests of the employees and shareholders. While these incentive programs provide a great benefit, they must be carefully managed to avoid upsetting your financial strategy or posing a significant tax burden. Below we discuss two of the most common stock option plans that we help our clients understand and maximize.

RSU – Restricted Stock Units

As an employee, you may receive a Restricted Stock Unit (RSU) grant as part of your annual performance assessment or generally as part of your overall compensation package. The majority of RSUs have a vesting schedule, so you don’t receive the full value from the outset (Your employer wants to schedule vesting over a period, rather than all at once, to retain your services!). For example, if your company grants you 400 RSUs, you’ll probably get 100 shares to vest each year (typically on a quarterly schedule) until you vest all 400 shares, at which time you may receive a new grant.

RSUs give you an interest in the company but no actual value until they are vested. Upon vesting, the Fair Market Value (FMV) of the shares is considered income. You will then have the right to sell the vested shares and receive the cash proceeds or hold the shares for a longer period.

Regarding Taxes

Your income will include the FMV of the shares as they vest. You can sell your vested shares and convert them to cash. Alternatively, you may keep the shares, but any gains made after the vesting date would be taxed as capital gains when you sell. If you hold shares and they drop in value, you might be faced with selling those shares at a loss, while paying tax on vesting date FMV you never actually received.

Your employer typically handles your tax withholding at the vesting date by selling enough shares on your behalf to cover the estimated tax liability and distributing the remainder to you. The IRS requires a statutory 22% withholding rate. Because your vested RSUs influence your taxable income, and effective tax bracket, your employer’s tax withholding rate may not be enough.

Strategy

RSUs accrue over time and, if held, can lead to a significantly consolidated position in one firm. An experienced executive might start with 100 shares vested, then 200, then 300, and so on. Suddenly, they discover that a sizable chunk of their holdings, perhaps also a significant percentage of their net worth, consists of company stock.

Accumulation of company stock can lead to more than just lack of portfolio diversification. Generally, having a sizable stock position in the same company that also pays your salary isn’t advisable. If that organization, for a myriad of reasons, experiences a downturn this could have a double-whammy effect.

As a result, it may be advisable to sell all RSUs as they vest. There should be no additional taxes owed, because your costs basis will be the FMV at which you received the stock. In fact, keeping RSUs as they vest is the exact same thing as taking each cash bonus and investing it 100% in your company stock. If you wouldn’t do that, you shouldn’t hold all of your RSUs. By converting the shares to cash you will be better able to manage taxes due and invest proceeds in a more diverse manner. This should provide you with greater and more predictable long-term success.

ISO – Incentive Stock Options

Incentive Stock Options (ISO) are issued by public companies or private companies planning to go public in the future. They are most typically offered to executives and highly valued employees and are designed to encourage these employees to stay with the company over the long term.

An ISO provides an ‘option’ to purchase shares in a company at a set price, called the ‘strike price’, for a specified period. Like RSUs, ISOs are typically subject to a vesting schedule that could be several years. As the ISOs vest, you can exercise them at the strike price stated in the grant. Employees may have 10 years to exercise their options before they expire. Once you exercise vested shares, you now own the shares at the strike price. You may hold them or sell them immediately, but there are several things to consider.

Regarding Taxes

When you exercise your ISOs, you don’t receive any proceeds, as the exercise is only the purchase of the stock. To qualify for the most favorable tax strategy, ISOs need to be held for 2 years from grant date and 1 year after exercise, allowing for Long Term Capital Gains (LTCG) treatment at sale. Pursuing this strategy, however, can trigger what is known as Alternative Minimum Tax, or AMT.

This tax liability is created by the spread, or difference between, the Fair Market Value (FMV) and the Strike price you were granted. This is often referred to as the ‘Bargain Element’, and if large enough, will create AMT. This can be very complex and confusing as many employees are unaware of this and are caught off guard by their sometimes-significant tax liability due to AMT. We help our clients understand the AMT involved with their ISO strategy, and the ways that they can use any excess AMT payments as credits against future taxes in years where they aren’t subject to AMT.

Another option for ISOs is to do a “cashless exercise,” which means you never actually purchase the stock at the strike price, but rather you are simply paid out the spread between the strike price and the current FMV. This is a good choice if you don’t want to worry about AMT, or if you don’t have the cash necessary to buy the shares at the strike price. However, this strategy will cause the spread to be taxed at ordinary income rates instead of capital gains rates, and it effectively forgoes the potential tax benefits offered by ISOs.

Strategy

We generally recommend exercising options as soon as they vest and holding for long term capital gains treatment. Your specific strategy may vary based on your goals, but reducing what could be a concentrated position, and reinvesting the proceeds in a more diverse portfolio can lead to more predictable long-term outcomes.

The Bottom Line:

The most common misconceptions about equity incentive programs relate to taxation and vesting.

  • RSU: Taxed immediately upon vesting using the FMV of the vested shares, usually vest over a period of years, and you can sell them as they vest. No tax benefit to holding after they vest.
  • ISO: Subject to vesting schedules, may create AMT liability when exercised and held, and must be held for 2 years from grant and 1 year from exercise to apply LTCG. Typically expire after 10 years.

If your employer offers these unique and valuable benefits, don’t let the financial planning overwhelm you.  Act today and consult with an experienced financial planner and a tax professional to develop a solid strategy for maximizing your wealth. If we can help you in any way, please don’t hesitate to contact us.

Nathan Garcia
About the Author

Nathan Garcia has served as a financial advisor and planner for individuals, families, and organizations since 2001. He understands the meaningful positive impact quality financial advice can have. He listens to clients needs…

Ask an Advisor

We’re here to help. You can use this form to get timely answers from a financial advisor — or give us a call to get the guidance you need.

"*" indicates required fields

Sign up for updates, insights, and notifications for new podcast episodes.

"*" indicates required fields